Skip to main content

EXCLUSIVE: 'Top-class performance' - Keith Hackett on the EPL referees during opening weekend

Premier League referee Jarred Gillett during the Manchester City vs Bournemouth match
Premier League referee Jarred Gillett during the Manchester City vs Bournemouth matchČTK / imago sportfotodienst / Conor Molloy

Former Premier League official, head of PGMOL and refereeing authority, Keith Hackett will be Flashscore's refereeing expert throughout the 2026/27 Premier League season, and will offer his observations and views on the performances of the English top-flight officials, their decision-making and any other talking points.

Arsenal vs Coventry City

Referee: Thomas Bramall

Video Assistant Referee: Jarred Gillett

Assistant Referee 1: Gary Beswick

Assistant Referee 2: Matt Wilkes

Fourth Official: Adam Herczeg

Assistant VAR Official: Neil Davies

"It took until the 28th minute for Thomas Bramall to brandish the first yellow card of the season, Coventry City’s Caleb Yirenkyi losing his footing in a shoulder-to-shoulder battle with Myles Lewis-Skelly, before the Coventry player showed signs of frustration and dragged his opponent back.

"It was the correct decision by the referee, who, up until then, had been able to adopt a low-key approach with minimal interference.

"Just seven minutes later, the Sky Blues' Ellis Simms beat Arsenal's Gabriel on the edge of the penalty area, and the Brazilian tugged him back to earn himself a deserved yellow card.

"A very quick review by VAR (Jarred Gillett at Stockley Park) to check for a possible handball determined that there should be no penalty kick, which was another correct decision made on the day by a group of officials who can be very satisfied with their start to the season."

Brentford vs Spurs

Referee: Michael Oliver

Video Assistant Referee: John Brooks

Assistant Referee 1: James Mainwaring

Assistant Referee 2: Blake Antrobus

Fourth Official: Samuel Barrott

Assistant VAR Official: Gary Beswick

"Not too much to report from the game at the Gtech Community Stadium, with referee Michael Oliver high on confidence after his participation at the World Cup.

"There was little for him to do, other than rightly awarding a penalty kick for a pushing offence. He was ideally positioned and, with no hesitation, pointed to the spot.

"A top-class performance."

Hull City vs Manchester United

Referee: Darren England

Video Assistant Referee: Michael Salisbury

Assistant Referee 1: Scott Ledger

Assistant Referee 2: Akil Howson

Fourth Official: Chris Kavanagh

Assistant VAR Official: Paul Howard

"Another game in which the official, on this occasion Darren England, delivered a good performance in a game that was easy to manage, with the players behaving well throughout."

Ipswich Town vs Sunderland

Referee: Farai Hallam

Video Assistant Referee: Nicholas Hopton

Assistant Referee 1: Adrian Holmes

Assistant Referee 2: Simon Long

Fourth Official: Andy Madley

Assistant VAR Official: Wade Smith

"Referee Farai Hallam, who is not long into his Premier League career, again demonstrated that he has a long career ahead of him.

"Very fit and mobile, he took up excellent viewing positions in good proximity to play, and barely put a foot wrong. Definitely one to watch in the future."

Everton vs Crystal Palace

Referee: Paul Tierney

Video Assistant Referee: Timothy Wood

Assistant Referee 1: Richard West

Assistant Referee 2: Mark Stevens

Fourth Official: Josh Smith

Assistant VAR Official: Adam Nunn

"Prime Minister Andy Burnham, a long-standing Everton fan, was in attendance at a game in which Palace were lucky to escape a penalty kick after a foul in the area.

Key match stats
Key match statsFlashscore

"A correct offside flag saved the Eagles, with the decision-making from both assistants and referee Paul Tierney first-class on the day.

"This was an excellent performance from Tierney, one of the senior EPL referees on the circuit."

Nottingham Forest vs Leeds United

Referee: Robert Jones

Video Assistant Referee: Craig Pawson

Assistant Referee 1: Nick Greenhalgh

Assistant Referee 2: Alistair Nelson

Fourth Official: Gavin Ward

Assistant VAR Official: Ian Hussin

"Ola Aina was shown a yellow card for a reckless challenge in the 18th minute, the Forest player fortunately keeping his leading foot low, and the official therefore correct in producing a yellow.

"Referee Jones delivered a performance with a good standard of decision-making throughout, including being in the right position to detect that reckless challenge.

"Leeds United's Harry Wilson will feel aggrieved that his goal was chalked off, though the offside decision was the correct one."

Manchester City vs Bournemouth

Referee: Jarred Gillett

Video Assistant Referee: Paul Howard

Assistant Referee 1: Neil Davies

Assistant Referee 2: Steven Meredith

Fourth Official: Robert Jones

Assistant VAR Official: Blake Antrobus

"Evanilson really should have received a yellow card for charging his opponent in the back, referee Gillett taking a lenient approach, which he didn't do when the number nine made a reckless challenge in first-half stoppage time.

"Phil Foden's yellow card in the 78th minute was also the correct decision from the official, as was the one handed to Antonio Silva for dissent.

"Josko Gvardiol's goal looked to have been ruled out by the assistant's flag, but a VAR check and the semi-automated system clearly showed that the Croatian was onside and the goal stood.

"Referee Gillett judged his involvement in the game well. He adopted a low-key approach, showing a willingness to communicate with players and, rather than brandish cards to assert his authority, he showed a degree of tolerance. 

"A good start to the season for him."

Brighton vs Aston Villa

Referee: Peter Bankes

Video Assistant Referee: Matt Donohue

Assistant Referee 1: Ian Hussin

Assistant Referee 2: Wade Smith

Fourth Official: Michael Salisbury

Assistant VAR Official: Craig Taylor

"Peter Bankes certainly had his work cut out in the early stages of this game, correctly showing three yellow cards between the ninth and 11th minutes for Brighton's Pascal Gross and Yasin Ayari, along with Aston Villa's Joao Gomes.

"Villa's John McGinn was the next to go in the book just after the half hour, in what was a feisty encounter, and this was followed by a red card for Gomes for violent conduct, after he kicked out with a high boot to the chest area of his opponent.

"The second half was much less intense both from a playing and officiating perspective, with a 95th-minute yellow for Matty Cash (reckless challenge), the only time referee Bankes had to reach for a card after the break.

"The official kept a firm grip on proceedings, and that approach, particularly in the first half, ensured that he was always in control of this one."

Newcastle United vs Liverpool

Referee: Stuart Attwell

Video Assistant Referee: James Bell

Assistant Referee 1: Constantine Hatzidakis

Assistant Referee 2: Lee Betts

Fourth Official: Tony Harrington

Assistant VAR Official: Edward Smart

"Wow, what an atmosphere at St. James' Park. The pre-match recognition of the late Kevin Keegan by the supporters of both teams was terrific. I add my condolences for a player I officiated on many occasions, with our paths also crossing when he went into management. A legend.

"The first yellow card of the match didn't arrive until the 25th minute, Newcastle's Yoane Wissa penalised for a pull-back that stopped a promising attack. The correct decision by referee Attwell.

Match momentum
Match momentumFlashscore

"Prior to half-time, and largely as a result of showing that first yellow, the official was left with little choice other than to card Milos Kerkez and Lewis Miley for reckless challenges, and Jeremy Frimpong for a clear holding offence (unsporting behaviour).

"After the break, Attwell continued to officiate really well, though a yellow card for Jacob Ramsey in the 65th minute, in the context of this match and the laws of the game, was harsh, and the incident could've been managed verbally.

"A 79th-minute yellow card for Jacob Murphy and an 89th-minute advantage played were both terrific decisions, whilst the bookings for both Virgil van Dijk and Lukas Hornicek were also correct."

How were the new laws interpreted on opening weekend?

"The opening games of the new season of the English Premier League got off to a good start.

"The new laws introduced to assist the positive flow of the game have worked extremely well, and it is hoped that referees will continue to ensure that they remain that way throughout the season.

"When the substitution boards were raised, we witnessed the swift exchange of players.

"Throw-ins and goal kicks with the five-second countdown applied have resulted in a positive response from the player in possession of the ball.

"Failure to meet the five-second throw-in timing will result in the throw-in being awarded to the opposition, and where the goal kick exceeds the five-second countdown by the referee, it will result in the award of a corner kick to the opposition.

"Over the weekend, I haven't witnessed the goalkeepers go down feigning injury to allow for a communication of a change of tactics by the offending team, and that can only be a positive."

Jason Pettigrove has been the features writer for Flashscore since 2025, utilising Opta data to form the basis of his articles. He has previously worked for high profile football clubs, news and media outlets, both in print and digital, and can usually be found watching FC Barcelona when time permits. You can read more of his pieces here.

Author
AuthorFlashscore

21+ | COMPETENT REGULATOR EEEP | RISK OF ADDICTION & LOSS OF PROPERTY | KETHEA HELPLINE: 210 9237777 | PLAY RESPONSIBLY & SAFELY |

Do you want to withdraw your consent to display betting ads?
Yes, change settings